Professor karl menger, illinois insti tute of technology has written footnotes 4,9, 10, and 15. Petersburg game has enjoyed a long life in the literatures of several academic diplines. Petersburg paradox is similar to that with my makeshift example. Petersburg in such a way as to get around this problem, by increasing payoffs by more than doubling them when suf. Peter offers to let paul toss a fair coin an indefinite number of times, paying him 2 ducats if heads first come up at the first toss, 4 ducats if it first comes up at the. The paradox occurs in particular in the setting and the parameter regime studied by tversky and kahneman 15 and in subsequent works. Petersburg paradox refers to the problem why most people are unwilling to participate in a fair game or bet. This problem does not occur in expected utility theory. A resolution of the st petersburg paradox is presented.
In view of the frequency with which bernoullis famous paper has been referred to in recent economic discussion, it has been thought appropriate to make it more. Petersburg lottery that leads to a random variable with infinite expected value, i. Petersburg paradox from probability theory and economics. Some probabilities lets begin by calculating probabilities associated with this game. A different response to the paradox is to try to explain it in terms of risk aversion.
Petersburg paradox is a paradox related to probability theory and decision theory. The paradox challenges the old idea that people value random ventures according to. Petersburg paradox, and applies the expected utility theory to solve it, as daniel bernoulli did. Petersburg paradox has been a source of contention within probability theory since its inception in the early 18th century 1. After 20,000 gameplays in this simulation the average winning per lottery was just under 8 dollars. The paradox describes a situation where a simple game of chance offers an infinite expected payoff, and yet any reasonable investor will pay no more than a few. In probabilistic terms, the size of the hypermeander trajectory proves to have an infinite expectation, despite being finite with probability one. In contrast to the standard resolution, utility is not required. Petersburg paradox daniel bernoullis solution lay in the realization that peoples utility, or the subjective, internal value they attach to an additional. A fair coin is to be tossed until the first time it comes up heads. Petersburg paradox, involved a bet with an exponentially increasing payoff. Petersburg paradox refers to only one such compound game, a dramatic and even overdramatic case. Foreword to the second edition ten new paradoxes have been added.
Petersburg paradox, named due to the 1738 publication of daniel bernoulli commentaries of the imperial academy of science of saint petersburg. Petersburg paradox stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. So there are now entries on 84 paradoxes, as well as the entry on paradoxitself. This assumption can be shown to be implausible by carefully analysing the physical meaning of the ensemble average. Whitworth was, in fact, seeking a solution to the petersburg problem that would be free of. The time resolution of the st petersburg paradox pdf. Thus, the st petersburg paradox relies for its existence on the assumption that the expected gain or growth factor or exponential growth rate is the relevant quantity for an individual deciding whether to take part in the lottery. Then you repeat this process a million times and use the data generated to study the distribution of the sample mean of 8 trials. Expected utility theory was first proposed as a solution to the st. Allais paradox, the cable guy, the charitable trust, the chicken and the egg, the paradox of interesting numbers, the muddy children, the numbered balls, the recent and striking parrondo paradox, the self amendment paradoxand the paradox of voting.
Petersburg paradox and capital asset pricing university of. Growth stocks and the petersburg paradox by david durand. Petersburg paradox has attracted great interest from researchers for 300 years neugebauer 2010. Also, we show the insu ciency of the historical solution, via the construction of a mengers superpetersburg paradox, when not using bounded utility functions.
Petersburg paradox is one of the most wellknown and interesting problems in the history of financial economics. If a head occurs for the rst time on the nth toss then you will be paid 2ndollars. The expected utility hypothesis stems from daniel bernoullis 1738 solution to the famous st. The 8t petersburg paradox has thus been enormously influential. Petersburg lottery a typical graph of average winnings over one course of a st.
We find that in cumulative prospect theory cpt with a concave value function in gains, a lottery with finite expected value may have infinite subjective value. Whitworth was, in fact, seeking a solution to the petersburg problem that would be free of arbitrary assumptions concerning the utility of money. Please read how you can help keep the encyclopedia free. It is based on a particular theoretical lottery game that leads to a random variable with infinite expected value i. Development of utility theory and utility paradoxes. It continues to be a reliable source for new puzzles and insights in decision theory. It is based on a particular theoretical lottery game sometimes called st. The purpose of this article is to demonstrate that contrary to the accepted view, the st petersburg game does notlead to a paradox at all. Peoples intuition is right, and nobody in their right mind would pay more than about five bucks to play this game.
A fair coin is flipped until it comes up heads the first time. Petersburg paradox from wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Econport handbook decisionmaking under uncertainty. Petersburg paradox is based on a simple coin flip game with an infinite expected winnings. Petersburg game a fair coin is tossed until it comes up heads for the first time. Petersburg paradox in real life, you can see the section on an experimental discussion of the st.
Mathematicians, economists, and psychologists have attempted to explain the paradox posed by the game since its introduction in the 18th century. This can be viewed as a physical manifestation of the classical st. Petersburg lottery is a paradox related to probability and. Petersburg paradox posed in 17 by his cousin nicholas bernoulli it is common to note that gabriel cramer, another swiss mathematician, also provided effectively the same solution ten years before bernoulli. Petersburg paradox wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. If it comes up heads on the first toss, the payment is 2 ducats.
Petersburg paradox today we want to direct our attention to daniel bernoullis clarification of a famous paradox in probability theory, concerning the st. Petersburg paradox,8 which challenges the expected value theory of utility, states. This paper describes the paradox, discusses its resolutions advanced in the literature while alluding to the historical context. Petersburg paradox as inapplicable to the valuation of growth stocks. Petersburg paradox lottery shows how occasional large payoffs lead to an overall very slow rise in average winnings. Pdf a resolution of the st petersburg paradox is presented. Pdf during the late 1990s high technology growth stock prices were raised to unprecedented levels by avid stock. The payoff is 2 guilders if this occurs at the first. Moreover, professor belden s views are countered by nancial analysts e. Petersburg paradox was introduced by nicolaus bernoulli in 17.
Graham, june 19, 2005 suppose you are o ered the chance to play the following game. Petersburg paradox and its history here, but here is the problem nicolaus bernoulli posed, which daniel bernoulli set out to solve in his book. A fair coin is tossed repeatedly until the first time it falls on head. Section 3 describes the st petersburg paradox, the first welldocumented example of a situation where the use of ensembles leads to absurd conclusions. For example, offer of participating in a gamble in which a person has even chance that. Petersburg lottery 1 is a paradox related to probability and decision theory in economics.
In that one, you would be comfortable with playing this game if you could borrow money indefinitely, so that even if you lost everything, you could use loans to keep playing the. Petersburg paradox indeed has a clear connection with the valuation of growth stocks. Petersburg paradox is based on the following simple game. Petersburg paradox wikimili, the free encyclopedia. You toss a coin, and if you get heads, you get bucks and the game ends. But bernoulli didnt close the book on this timehonored conundrum. Petersburg paradox is a famous economic and philosophical puzzle that. The petersburg paradox has led to much thought for three centuries. St petersburg paradox pdf petersburg lottery is a paradox related to probability and.
18 835 242 183 1621 185 455 107 1573 1017 466 1194 1485 809 222 304 430 621 121 817 183 894 54 342 710 1412 1048 1095 614 125 1393 1069 482 1074 880 608 1360 641 1467